Three National Football League teams over the past month have unveiled new logos, or changes to their old one, and all three have had extravagant events this past week to show the world the new uniforms that the players will don to match those logos. I do not think that each of them were a success. I do not think that all of them are a complete failure. I do, however, think that they can easily be ranked against each other with a clear cut number one.
Here are my rankings of the three new uniforms and logos.
#3 – Jacksonville Jaguars
As I mentioned before, the new logo at first did not impress me as I thought it looked to feminine to be a professional football team logo. Then it grew on me for the simple fact that it now looks more realistic for all the reasons that the old logo did not. The ear looks like an ear, the patches on the fur now look like patches, the whiskers look like whiskers, and so on. I also like the way that the team changed the way the tongue looked as is now has a more natural flow. I did not see anything wrong with the old tongue shape, I just believe the new one was a good choice. I do still find it weird that the tongue is that teal color, now joined by half of the nose and the eye, but it is a style design that I understand and ultimately I think that it gives the logo more of a pop.
The jerseys are not all that hateful. They unveiled three new tops, a black, white, and teal, along with two new pants, a black and a white. The sleeves for each of the jerseys are a different color than the main color of the jersey and each of the jerseys have these scratch like stripes on their shoulders that look to be the same color of the jersey just a different type of fabric. The font decision is consistent with the new script they use on logo featuring their name, however the outlining colors are not consistent and bother me. I have the same issue with the strips on the pants. They try to use as many colors as they can for the numbers and the striping on the pants and I don’t think in the end it works in the overall uniform scheme (I think they work each individually, but not together).
The downfall to these new dreads for the Jaguars, and the reason they are ranked last (out of the new uniform designs) is there new dreadful looking helmets. I mean if you think that these helmets you are one of the four; colorblind, a naive Jaguar fan trying to convince yourself that they look good, an overwhelming college football fan, or simply a fool. To me they would be ranked last out of all NFL teams helmets they are that bad. The helmets have the Jaguar head logo place in the middle, like most teams do, then have the color “fade” from black to gold. I use quotation marks on the word fade because there is very little resemblance of any fading; to me it looks more like one color stops and the other color begins. I think that the idea is okay, not great, but the execution was horrendous. If the “fade” would have been more prominent I think it would have looked a tad better, but two colors like that on a NFL helmet should not happen. The designer at NIKE said that the color change was due to the fact that Jaguars hunt from the shadows, however the logo appears be hunting from the sun into the shadows so therefore his explanation makes no sense. The owner of the team called the idea “revolutionary,” I call it a joke.
The one thing that I absolutely love about the new uniforms is the military inspired patches that are placed on the left peck with the Jaguar facing towards the heart, as they do in the military.
Overall the new logo is a vast improvement, the jerseys aren’t that bad, and the helmets are terrible.
#2 – Miami Dolphins
When I first saw the Dolphins’ new logo I immediately disliked it and, unlike the Jaguars logo, I still think that it is pretty ridiculous. Okay, so yes I know the dolphin featured in the logo has more of a realistic flow to it and the older logo depicted a dolphin wearing a football helmet, which isn’t possible, but the older logo represented the franchise better in my opinion. Another thing that the old logo has over the new one is the way the dolphin is shaped. In the now old logo the dolphin appears to be leaping out of the water, which makes the part about the sun being behind the dolphin. The new logo the dolphin appears to be swimming, which makes the sun in the background confusing. The only way the sun can be in the background of a picture with a dolphin swimming, as is the case, the sun would need to be underwater, or the dolphin would have to be the first of its kind to be able to fly, almost like the whales in the movie Anastasia. I personally did not think anything wrong with the old dolphins’ logo, however if they wanted something new they should have done something such as this photo I found on the internet. I think it would have been a better choice.
Design I thought would have been a better choice. |
Now let us move on to the jerseys themselves. The jerseys, like the Jaguars, are not hateful and they will be something that fans will easily buy and wear. This being said, I think that there is too much teal in the uniforms and not enough orange. The Dolphins have always enough orange in the uniform to counter-balance the teal they decided to wear. These jerseys do not have that orange and I personally think that the teal is over bearing. The numbers seem to have random points in which one area of each of the number seems to curve which gives a bubble letter effect and makes the style goofy looking because other areas of the numbers have straight edges (look at the top left and then the top right of the numbers 2, 3, and 9 to see my point). They did a good job in keeping the outlining colors consistent with both the white and the teal jersey numbers outlined by what it seems to be orange and a darker teal color. The color of the numbers will be teal on the white jerseys and white on the teal jerseys, again keeping it simple so that the outlining numbers can match on both.
The Dolphins will only showcase two new pants, like the jerseys, a white one and a teal one. The design scheme from the numbers can also be seen here on the pants. The pants will have stripes down the side of each leg that will showcase a larger (2 inch or so) stripe that, like the numbers, will be white or teal depending on the pants color. Two much smaller stripes will be on the each side of that stripe and will be the same darker teal and the orange that also outline the numbers. I do not think they are bad and I like the idea of a solid theme, however the teal still over powers the orange to the point that the orange almost seems unnoticeable.
The helmets for the Dolphins will be the traditional white and will show the new dolphin-sun logo on both of the side. One of the changes is that the facemask will be white. It is not a bad look, but I would have liked to seen the Dolphins make the facemask orange, again to even out the colors (For those who were wondering the old Dolphins helmet featured a teal facemask). The Dolphins, continuing to do a great job keeping everything similar, made the stripe down the center helmet the same stripe that is seen on the white pants. Overall not a bad helmet like the Jaguars, but nothing special about them either. They are middle of the road.
Overall the Dolphins changed a logo that did not need to be fixed and focus on the color teal too heavily; they are just one step above the Jaguars new look (and that is only because of the Jags helmet).
# 1 – Minnesota Vikings
By far the Minnesota Vikings unveiled the best new look to the world, I mean it was not even close. If it were a race it would be Usian Bolt versus Fat Albert in the 100m. The Vikings kept the traditional Norseman logo, they just made a few tweaks to make it bolder and stand out better. The horns are cleaner without the scratchy black marks in them, the braid in the hair is shorter and thicker, and the lines throughout the hair and face are now thicker giving a more detailed look. These are all slight changes, but overall it gives the team a newer, cleaner look.
The helmet upgrade is truly remarkable and is a good mix between
traditional design and a new look. Like the jersey the helmets are a
darker colored purple. The horn on the helmet remains, but the helmet
does not have a gloss look on it anymore as the helmet now has a matte
finish, which makes the look "more manly" according to DE Jared Allen.
The facemask has also been changed from purple to black and allows the
helmet to have an extra kick.
Overall the Vikings did a tremendous jobs combining a traditional
look with new ideas. I absolutely love these new Vikings dreads.
Well those are the new looks that will be on the backs of several
NFL teams this fall. If your team has not announced any changes do not
expect anything new from them as it is a very complicated process of
changing uniforms in the National Football League. Also, the NFL has
a five year rule that states that teams cannot change their logo or
uniforms if they had previously done so within the last five years.
Hope you were satisfied with your team's draft, I know I am.
-JM
LIKE on Facebook: Hitting A Touchdown
Follow on Twitter: @hitting_a_td